A primary care physician reviewing practice financials on a tablet in a bright modern clinic

Cash-Pay and Membership Practice Models in 2026: Why 27% of Primary Care Physicians Are Making the Shift

September 18, 2026•12 min read

If you've searched for whether independent physicians are actually leaving insurance for cash-pay or membership models, most of what you'll find is either a sales pitch for a specific model or a hand-waving "the system is broken" take. The real question is narrower and more useful: what is the data actually showing, what's driving clinicians to change how they get paid, and what does it mean for the practice you run today.

This guide walks through a 2026 dataset on the question — Elation Health's Primary Care Pulse survey — explains the reimbursement math behind the shift, breaks down the three payment models the survey measured, and covers a federal rule change that took effect January 1, 2026 and lowered one barrier to direct primary care. It ends with a practical positioning checklist and the compliance questions you should run past your board and health-law counsel.

A physician reviewing a payment-model dashboard on a laptop in a modern clinic

Quick answer

Elation Health's April 2026 survey of 280 independent-leaning primary care clinicians found that 27% of insurance-participating physicians have already adopted membership or cash-pay models, and 18% have moved to value-based payment. Reimbursement was the top financial pressure, cited by 64%, while more than 80% reported concern about long-term financial sustainability. And 67% reported planning implementation of changes within two years.

What the 2026 Elation survey actually found

Elation Health released its first "Primary Care Pulse" survey on April 16, 2026, drawing on 280 predominantly independent primary care clinicians, surveyed between January 31 and February 23, 2026. The sample skews independent: 52% of respondents were fully unaffiliated with any health system, IPA, CIN, or ACO, and 70% had been practicing for 11 years or more.

Three headline numbers matter most. First, more than 80% of respondents said they are concerned about their long-term financial sustainability. Second, 64% named reimbursement from government and commercial payers as their single biggest financial pressure — well ahead of staffing, technology, and overhead costs. Third, among physicians who still participate in insurance, 27% have added a membership or cash-pay model, and another 18% have adopted value-based payment structures.

One notable finding is that few respondents are heading for the exit. Only 2% of Elation respondents said they were considering leaving primary care, versus other national surveys that Elation says report figures as high as 44%. A full 80% reported feeling joy in their work at least weekly, and 93% said they remain committed to primary care despite the financial pressure.

Dr. Sara Pastoor, Elation Health's head of primary care advancement, framed the shift this way: "Independent primary care physicians aren't waiting for the system to change; they're already taking action. They're rejecting the idea that a career in medicine has to come at the expense of their personal lives, and instead are embracing new payment models and technologies that support both."

Two caveats are worth keeping in mind before you lean on these numbers. This is the survey's first year, so there is no year-over-year trend yet. And because the sample was predominantly independent and the survey comes from a company press release rather than an academic journal, it is best read as a portrait of independent primary care specifically, not all primary care nationally.

The reimbursement math behind the shift

The single most common reason clinicians give for adding a cash-pay or membership line is that reimbursement no longer covers the cost of running the practice. In the Elation survey, 64% named reimbursement as their top financial challenge, with staffing, technology, and overhead layered on top.

Kyna Fong, CEO and co-founder of Elation Health, puts the core problem as a structural mismatch. The United States invests "only 5%-7% of healthcare spend in primary care, compared with about 14% in other developed countries," according to Healthcare Finance News. "That underinvestment shows up directly in reimbursement."

The professional-society literature agrees with the diagnosis, if not always with the fix. A 2026 editorial in Primer, the Society of Teachers of Family Medicine's journal, says that long-standing reimbursement disparities within fee-for-service "reward utilization over outcomes," while "value-based care shifts financial risk and administrative burden onto clinicians." The editorial is direct that no dominant payment model currently supports the financial sustainability of primary care practices — which is exactly the gap that cash-pay and membership models are filling.

That does not mean the switch is automatic or easy. Fong's read, as quoted by Healthcare Finance News, on what separates the practices that make it work: "We see practices operating under membership, cash-pay, value-based arrangements, and hybrid models. Some are thriving; others are struggling. The difference is whether they have the infrastructure to support the model effectively."

Cash-pay, membership, and value-based: what's actually different

The survey groups "membership or cash-pay" into a single 27% figure, but they are not the same thing, and it matters when you're deciding which one fits your practice.

  • Cash-pay means the patient pays you directly for each service, with no insurance billing for that service line.

  • Membership (direct primary care, or DPC) means the patient pays a fixed periodic fee — usually monthly — for a defined set of primary care services, and you don't bill a third party for those services.

  • Value-based payment means you still contract with a payer, but reimbursement is tied to quality or outcome measures rather than (or in addition to) service volume.

Membership / cash-pay

Value-based payment

How you're paid

Directly by the patient — a per-service fee or a fixed periodic fee

By a payer, tied to quality/outcome measures

Insurance billing

No, for the covered services

Yes, via payer contracts

Adoption in the 2026 Elation survey

27% of insurance-participating physicians

18%

HSA treatment of fees (2026)

DPC fees: tax-free from HSA funds, with monthly caps (see below)

Not addressed by the IRS notice

Documented tradeoff

Removes payer constraints on the practice, but limits access for patients without financial means (per STFM)

Retains payer contracts; shifts financial risk and administrative burden onto the clinician (per STFM)

A nurse practitioner reviewing financial charts in a bright clinic office

The 27% and 18% figures are not mutually exclusive in practice — a practice can layer a cash-pay service line on top of insurance volume, which is precisely the "hybrid" model Fong describes. What the survey shows is that adoption of non-traditional payment is already meaningful and concentrated in the independent segment.

The 2026 HSA rule change that lowered the DPC barrier

One structural barrier to direct primary care was removed at the start of 2026, and it's worth understanding because it affects how patients can pay you.

Until 2026, direct primary care enrollment was not protected for HSA purposes. That changed under the One, Big, Beautiful Bill Act (Pub. L. 119-21, enacted July 4, 2025), with guidance in IRS Notice 2026-5, issued December 9, 2025.

Starting January 1, 2026, two things changed for arrangements that qualify as a "direct primary care service arrangement" (DPCSA):

  1. Enrollment in a qualifying DPCSA no longer disqualifies the patient from HSA contributions.

  2. The patient can use HSA funds tax-free to pay the periodic DPC fees.

The IRS defines a DPCSA as care consisting "solely of primary care services provided by primary care practitioners" for a fixed periodic fee as the sole compensation. "Primary care practitioners" include physicians in family medicine, internal medicine, geriatric medicine, or pediatrics, as well as nurse practitioners, clinical nurse specialists, and physician assistants. The definition also draws a boundary on what "primary care services" means: it excludes procedures requiring general anesthesia, prescription drugs other than vaccines, and lab services not typically done in an ambulatory primary care setting.

There is a dollar cap on the eligibility side. To keep HSA-eligible status, the aggregate monthly fee must stay at or below $150 for an individual, or $300 for an arrangement covering more than one person, adjusted annually for inflation starting after 2026. An arrangement priced above the cap does not fit the DPCSA definition, so confirm with a tax advisor or health-law counsel how it would be treated before you price around it.

The honest counterweight comes from the STFM editorial, which says direct primary care, while enhancing patient relationships and liberating physicians from payer constraints, "limits access for patients without financial means." A cash-pay or membership model solves the reimbursement problem for the practice, but it does not solve access for everyone. Keep that tension in mind when you're positioning your model, because it's the first thing a skeptical colleague — or a reporter — will raise.

Positioning your practice for the shift

If the data convinces you to move, the sequence matters more than the model choice. Here is a practical order of operations, built from what the survey and the IRS guidance actually say.

  1. Audit your payer mix before you change anything. Know what share of revenue is reimbursement-dependent and where the margin pressure actually is. The survey's signal is that reimbursement is the top pressure for 64% of practices — confirm that's true for yours before restructuring around it.

  2. Pick a lane — or a deliberate hybrid. Decide whether you're adding a cash-pay service line, moving to a full membership model, or layering cash-pay on top of insurance volume. The survey shows all three are being used; what matters is that the choice is intentional.

  3. Check scope-of-practice and supervision rules first. A membership or cash-pay arrangement changes how you get paid, not your license. Confirm with your state licensing board and health-law counsel that your structure — especially any NP/PA supervision or corporate-practice requirements — is valid in your state.

  4. If you want HSA-eligible patients, structure the arrangement as a DPCSA. Fixed periodic fee as the sole compensation, primary care services only, and fees at or under $150 (individual) / $300 (family) per month. This is a specific IRS definition — match it if HSA treatment matters to your patients.

  5. Build the infrastructure Fong says separates the winners. According to Healthcare Finance News, she points to purpose-built technology, integration with the broader healthcare system, and predictable cash flow. "Without that foundation, even the best-designed models create operational strain," she said.

  6. Price against your costs. Don't assume results from anyone else's numbers. A model's viability depends on your local market and your cost structure, not on anyone else's claimed numbers.

A physician explaining a care plan to a seated patient in a warm clinic room

Watch for misinformation: The claim that "everyone is going cash-pay" is not what the data says. The 27% figure is specific to insurance-participating physicians in an independent-leaning sample, and 18% reported adopting value-based payment. Treat any "cash-pay is the only way" narrative with the same skepticism you'd apply to "insurance is the only way."

What this means for you: The direction of travel is real and measurable — reimbursement pressure is pushing a meaningful minority of independent clinicians toward direct-payment models, and federal policy just removed a tax barrier to one of them. But the model is not the moat. Execution and infrastructure are, and those are under your control.

If you're ready to add a cash-pay service line, the practical starting point for many clinicians is IV therapy — see our guide to launching an IV therapy service and what certification your state actually requires.

The bottom line

The Elation survey indicates that independent primary care clinicians feel reimbursement pressure and are responding — 27% with membership or cash-pay models, 18% with value-based payment, and 67% planning implementation of changes within two years. Elation's CEO attributes the pressure to underinvestment in primary care, and since January 1, 2026 patients can use HSA funds for qualifying direct primary care fees. The clinicians who make the transition work are the ones who treat the payment model as a business decision with real infrastructure requirements — not a slogan.

Frequently asked questions

How many primary care physicians run cash-pay or membership models?

According to Elation Health's April 2026 survey, 27% of insurance-participating primary care physicians have adopted a membership or cash-pay model, and another 18% have adopted value-based payment structures.

What's driving physicians away from insurance reimbursement?

Reimbursement is the top pressure. In the same survey, 64% of respondents named reimbursement from government and commercial payers as their biggest financial challenge, and more than 80% said they're concerned about long-term financial sustainability.

What's the difference between direct primary care and cash-pay?

Cash-pay means the patient pays directly per service with no insurance billing. Direct primary care (DPC) means the patient pays a fixed periodic fee for a defined set of primary care services. The Elation survey groups the two together in its 27% figure.

Can patients use HSA funds to pay for direct primary care?

Yes, starting January 1, 2026. Under IRS Notice 2026-5, HSA funds can be used tax-free to pay fees for a qualifying direct primary care arrangement, and enrollment no longer disqualifies a patient from HSA contributions.

What are the HSA fee limits for direct primary care?

To keep HSA-eligible status, the aggregate monthly fee must stay at or below $150 for an individual, or $300 for an arrangement covering more than one person. These limits adjust annually for inflation after 2026.

Is value-based payment a cash-pay model?

No. Value-based payment means you still contract with a payer, but reimbursement is tied to quality or outcome measures rather than service volume. In the 2026 survey, 18% of insurance-participating physicians had adopted value-based payment.

Is independent primary care actually unsustainable?

Elation's report challenges the narrative that independent primary care is unsustainable, though it reflects a predominantly independent sample. Only 2% of respondents said they were considering leaving primary care, 93% said they remain committed, and 80% reported feeling joy in their work at least weekly — even while most were concerned about finances.

Ready to act on what the data shows? The most common first step is adding a single cash-pay service line and building it deliberately rather than bolting it on. The IV Therapy Course walks through the clinical and operational setup for one cash-pay service line, from protocols to the business fundamentals. Or start with the free peptide training to see whether the model fits before you commit.

This article is for educational purposes for licensed healthcare professionals and is not legal advice. Scope of practice and cash-pay and membership rules vary by state; confirm requirements with your licensing board and health-law counsel.

Sources

Custom HTML/CSS/JavaScript
Back to Blog
Adam Sewell, MD
About the author

Adam Sewell, MD

Board-certified physician and founder of Medical Entrepreneur. He built a cash-pay practice around regenerative and integrative medicine and hosts the Medical Entrepreneur podcast, with 200+ episodes on clinicians building beyond insurance.

More about Dr. Sewell →
Ready to launch?

Open your IV service with protocols you can stand behind.

The IV Therapy Program gives you the clinical protocols and the business system to launch safely, including medical direction, scope and state compliance.

  • Full formulary, including NAD+
  • Sterile technique and compounding
  • Pricing and membership models
$197one time · lifetime access
Enroll in the IV Therapy Program Not ready? Start with the free training